You might have been asked to show what a website said on a certain date: that an ad ran, a disclosure was shown, a story was published, or someone copied your brand. It could be one page. Or your system could capture pages all day, and one of those captures ends up in a dispute. Whatever the reason, the question is the same: is a screenshot admissible as evidence?
The short answer is: yes, website screenshots can be admissible. US, English and EU courts have all relied on screenshots as evidence in proceedings. [1] [2] [3] Captures taken by a system can work too, if someone can explain how it takes them. [4] Screenshots do sometimes get disputed, though, and getting one accepted isn't the same as proving your point: a court or jury can give it little weight, [4] and it shows what a page said, not that it was true.
This is the first article in a series on screenshots as evidence. It's not legal advice, and I'm not a lawyer.
What gets a screenshot disputed?
In the cases I read, the issue is rarely whether courts accept screenshots in general. It's whether the other party disputes yours. When they do, in US courts, someone usually has to authenticate it, meaning show it's what you say it is. That's often the person who took it. In English civil cases, a document handed over in the case is treated as genuine unless the other side formally asks you to prove it. [5]
And when a dispute happens, it's usually not a real claim of tampering. Anyone can edit a page in their browser, but courts want more than that possibility. [3] [6] It's more often about who can vouch for it and what it shows: nobody who took it has sworn to it, [7] it's from the wrong date, [8] the page looks different depending on how you reach it, [9] or it's a recreation of the page. [10] Those last two arguments lost, but they do come up.
Here's what that looks like in real cases:
- The wrong date. In one US case, the screenshots were from 2017, the bookings were from 2016, and the witness couldn't show the sites looked the same back then, so the screenshots were excluded at that stage. [8]
- Nobody said who took it. In another, a lawyer's statement didn't say who took the screenshots or when, so the court wouldn't consider them. [7]
How do I make a screenshot that holds up?
A screenshot you took yourself can be enough, if you can swear to it and the screenshot shows details that back you up, such as the URL or date. [6] [7] To give yourself the best chance, keep:
- The full URL and a timestamp.
- The whole page with nothing hidden, and every step if it's a flow.
- Desktop and mobile, if the case could turn on either.
- Who took it or which system did, how, and on what device or settings.
- When you need it, a sworn statement from whoever took it or runs the system, saying what they did and that the capture is accurate.
- The original file, untouched.
Being pixel perfect is not what wins the case. What matters is whether the capture can back up a claim, so a missing section, a popup or cookie banner over the key text, or content that hadn't loaded can make it useless. A customer can dispute it long before any court sees it.
What if the page has already changed?
Looking into the past is not possible unless someone was already capturing the page. Your best chance is usually the Wayback Machine.
Important: it's not as simple as printing the archived page. In one US case, the Internet Archive's office manager explained how it captures pages and confirmed the screenshots matched its records, and that was enough to get them in. In an earlier civil case, with no such testimony, Wayback screenshots were kept out. [4]
If the page still exists and might change, capture it today. If you'll need proof of it later, capture it on a schedule from now on.
Can automated screenshots be used as evidence?
They can, but there's less to go on. I haven't found a ruling on a company's own system capturing other people's pages, and the rules vary by country. The closest example is the one above: the Internet Archive's captures got in because someone could explain how they were made. [4] In the US, a certification from someone qualified can sometimes replace that witness, though the other side can still challenge the capture or object for other reasons. [11]
So if your system takes the captures, keep a record of how each one was made, and know who could explain it. If you're running your own Chrome, Puppeteer or Playwright setup, that person is on your team.
What can't a screenshot prove?
Unfortunately, even a perfect screenshot still doesn't prove everyone saw the same webpage at the same time. A/B tests, localised webpages, different devices and many other variables can change what a webpage shows to a specific user. I'll come back to it later in this series.
References
- Luxottica Group S.p.A. v. Zhao, No. 16 C 7988, Dkt. 133, pp. 6-12 (N.D. Ill. 17 March 2017). govinfo.gov
- Industrial Cleaning Equipment (Southampton) Ltd v Intelligent Cleaning Equipment Holdings Co, Ltd & Ors [2023] EWHC 411 (IPEC) (27 February 2023), para 54. caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk
- JMS Sports v EUIPO, Case T-823/19 (General Court, 20 October 2021), paras 27, 37, 41 and 49. eur-lex.europa.eu
- United States v. Gasperini, No. 17-2479, Dkt. 78-1, pp. 14-16 (2d Cir. 2 July 2018). govinfo.gov
- Civil Procedure Rules (England and Wales), Part 32, rule 32.19. justice.gov.uk
- Pietrangelo v. Refresh Club, Inc., No. 18-cv-1943 (DLF), Dkt. 134, pp. 24-26 (D.D.C. 29 September 2023). govinfo.gov
- Iglesia Ni Cristo v. Cayabyab, No. 18-cv-00561-BLF, Dkt. 135, Order on Motion for Summary Judgment, pp. 6-8 (N.D. Cal. 31 March 2020). govinfo.gov
- Bacon v. Avis Budget Group, Inc., No. 18-3780, Dkt. 99, pp. 22-23 (3d Cir. 18 May 2020). govinfo.gov
- La Force v. GoSmith, Inc., No. 17-cv-05101-YGR, Dkt. 28, pp. 5-6 (N.D. Cal. 12 December 2017). govinfo.gov
- Hook v. Intelius, Inc., No. 5:10-CV-239 (MTT), Dkt. 51, pp. 2-9 (M.D. Ga. 28 March 2011). govinfo.gov
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 902(11) and (13), with the Committee Notes on the 2017 Amendment. law.cornell.edu
